THE death of a prisoner in the Junee Correctional Centre was preventable and his prospects of survival were good if an ambulance had been called to the jail at an earlier stage, a coroner said yesterday.
Deputy state coroner Carl Milovanovich made the comment yesterday in handing down his findings at the end of an inquest into the death of David Robert Kentwell.
Mr Milovanovich found that 43-year-old Mr Kentwell died at the Junee District Hospital on January 27, 2008, from an acute myocardial infarction due to coronary atherosclerosis.
The coroner said he was satisfied staff at the prison's medical clinic had concerns for Mr Kentwell's welfare and made reasonable attempts to diagnose his condition and provide what they considered to be appropriate care.
However, he said there was little doubt the diagnosis was incorrect.
"The avoidable death of Mr Kentwell should serve as a reminder to medical and clinical staff that any prisoner who presents with continuing chest pain or discomfort that the first consideration should be to place high on any provisional diagnosis the possibility that the patient may be experiencing a cardiac event," Mr Milovanovich said.
He said if Mr Kentwell had presented to a hospital or a doctor's surgery at 9.30am � the time he went to the jail medical clinic � he would have have had an electrocardiograph (ECG) test immediately and monitored closely.
However, Mr Kentwell did not have an ECG until 1pm and an ambulance was called at 2.27pm when he started fitting after having a heart attack.
n Continued Page 2
n From Page 1
"Mr Kentwell lost his liberty due to his criminal behaviour, however, a prisoner in custody should not receive any lesser medical attention to that that can be afforded to any other member of the community," Mr Milovanovich said.
He said the Junee jail's location - 40 kilometres from Wagga Base Hospital - may make it more prudent for jail clinical staff to err on the side of caution.
"By the time Mr Kentwell was fitting the prognosis would have been poor and he now faced the problem that time was against a possible recovery as it would and did take the Ambulance Service 14 minutes before they could provide medical treatment," Mr Milovanovich said.
Mr Milovanovich said the fact that the jail's only doctor, Richard Baguley, could not be contacted on his telephones between 1.26pm and 2.39pm was a matter of concern.
Dr Baguley was off duty the day Mr Kentwell died, but is always on call.
Nursing staff tried to phone Dr Baguley for his advice as they became increasingly concerned about Mr Kentwell's deteriorating condition, but could not reach him.
"It has to be accepted that any person who is on call 24/7 cannot realistically be available immediately for every minute or hour of that period," Mr Milovanovich said.
"That said, however, it would not be unreasonable for such on call personnel to check their mobile phones periodically - after all, are they not remunerated for this very duty?
"I do not wish to be overly critical of Dr Baguley, that is not the role of the coroner; however, I do find it most perplexing that he has so little memory of the status of his phone, whether he received any missed calls and very little recollection of any messages on his home answering service.
"Dr Baguley's failing memory of the events of this day do not sit comfortably with this court.
"After all, how often does a patient die while you are in a (movie) theatre and you subsequently become aware the patient has died during the period when no less than eight calls are made to the mobile and home phone number?"
The family of Mr Kentwell did not want to comment to the media after the coroner handed down his findings.